Archive for March 12th, 2010


Hate Mail

March 12, 2010

Here’s some enjoyable hate mail from third graders on the question of whether Pluto is a planet.

“It’s not easy being a public enemy,” writes Neil deGrasse Tyson in his book The Pluto Files. When Neil’s museum grouped Pluto not among the planets but rather with icy comets in an obscure region called the Kuiper Belt, he heard from thousands of outraged Pluto defenders. It’s tough being called a heartless Pluto-hater, particularly by a dismayed eight-year-old. In this slide show, peruse a few of the letters elementary schoolkids sent Neil, and see how their tone shifted over the years, as the public slowly came to accept Pluto’s fall from planethood.—Susan K. Lewis

Note: The correspondence in this slide show originally appeared in The Pluto Files(Norton, 2009).