Monbiot Misfires

March 17, 2010

This recent missive from George Monbiot pontificates about the trouble that scientists are now facing from a skeptical public, but he’s aiming at the wrong targets. Namely, I want to take issue with one nit-picky point of his. Check this out:

Views like [the cynical pissing and moaning of  windbag Gerald Warner] can be explained partly as the revenge of the humanities students. There is scarcely an editor or executive in any major media company – and precious few journalists – with a science degree, yet everyone knows that the anoraks are taking over the world.

I call bullshit. How the hell does Gerald Warner’s ridiculous article single-handedly indict the non-empirical side of the academy? Why pick on humanities students? What has humanities ever done to science?

Okay, sure, some humanists are complete fucking idiots. This isn’t a fault of the humanities. This is a fault of the fucking idiots who major in, and sometimes profess in, the humanities.

Same can be said for scientists. Some scientists are complete fucking idiots. This isn’t a fault of the sciences. Again, it’s the fault of the idiots.

Idiots bring it on themselves. Bad reasoning abounds, ladies and gents. It’s the job of academics — humanists and scientists alike — to unpack and dispel bad reasoning. Why create divisions where they don’t exist?

Second, if climate scientists need an ally in the public policy battle, they need look no further than the humanities. Why?  Because it is in the humanities that people study all manner of value and behavior that will or maybe can influence public policy. Here is where collaboration can happen, kiddos, where the critical discussions about right and wrong, good and bad, just and unjust, all take place. The humanities are where the human re-enters the object-oriented picture. The views thrown around in the humanities, coupled with the observations introduced by the sciences, will either galvanize or set the trajectory for most of our contemporary policy discussion.

Yeah, yeah, I know Monbiot is introducing some half-baked psychological picture about the power of misinformation. That’s interesting. It really is. But it doesn’t explain whey we get this silly criticism of the humanities.

I just want to make sure we don’t, in hasty irony, jump to conclusions and propose that the scientists can row this boat alone. We need scientific input in the climate debate, to be certain, but we can’t rely on scientists alone. Rah, rah home crowd.


  1. I sympathize.

    It is always irritating when your ox is the one being gored.

  2. Bastardi isn’t a scientist.

  3. s’ok, Eli knows several who meet the fucking idiot standard.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: